Modernising Legacy Systems: How to Upgrade Without Starting From Scratch

The 15-year-old system holds operations together - but nobody dares to touch it. No wonder: 70% of all legacy modernisations fail. But there are approaches that work.

Table of Contents

1. What Is a Legacy System Really?
2. Why Modernisation Often Fails
3. The 6 Modernisation Strategies
4. Step-by-Step: The Safe Path
5. Costs and ROI
6. When You Should NOT Modernise
7. Practical Checklist

---

What Is a Legacy System Really?

Definition: It's Not About Age

A system is "legacy" when it:

Accumulates technical debt:

• Nobody understands the entire code anymore
• Changes take disproportionately long
• Every adjustment carries unpredictable risks

Limits business:

• New requirements can't be implemented
• Integration with modern tools impossible
• Performance no longer sufficient

Creates organisational problems:

• Developers don't want to work on it
• Knowledge concentrated with few people
• Documentation missing or outdated

Typical Legacy Scenarios

Scenario	Example	Main Problem
Custom development	Access database from 2005	No maintainability
Outdated platform	Lotus Notes, FoxPro	No more support
Over-customised standard software	SAP with 500 custom reports	Upgrade impossible
Organically grown system	Excel + VBA as "ERP"	No scalability

The True Costs of Legacy

Direct costs:

• Maintenance: 60-80% of IT budget
• Specialists: 2-3x market salary
• Downtime: €10,000-€100,000/hour

Indirect costs:

• Missed opportunities (features not implementable)
• Slow market reaction
• Employee frustration
• Security risks

---

Why Modernisation Often Fails

Mistake 1: Big Bang Migration

The promise: "Everything will be new in 18 months."

The reality:

• Month 6: Unforeseen complexity
• Month 12: Budget exceeded
• Month 18: System not finished
• Month 24: Project cancelled, old system continues

Why it fails:

• Requirements change during development
• Business knowledge isn't documented
• Parallel operation overwhelms organisation
• Risk concentrated in one moment

Mistake 2: 1:1 Rebuild

The promise: "We'll build exactly the same, just more modern."

The reality:

• All bad decisions are carried over
• "That's how we've always done it" instead of improvement
• Expensive redevelopment without added value

Better: Rethink business processes, don't just migrate technically.

Mistake 3: Underestimated Complexity

What everyone sees: The surface

What nobody sees:

• 847 undocumented edge cases
• Workarounds that became features
• Integration with 23 other systems
• Data quality problems

Mistake 4: Lacking Stakeholder Involvement

What happens:

• IT plans, business learns late
• Users aren't asked
• Management underestimates effort
• Resistance at go-live

---

The 6 Modernisation Strategies

1. Encapsulate

Concept: Put modern APIs in front of legacy system.

Old UI → [Legacy System] → Old Database
                 ↓
            [API Layer]
                 ↓
New App → [Modern Services] → [Legacy System]

Advantages:

• No changes to legacy system needed
• Quick to implement
• Minimal risk

Disadvantages:

• Legacy problems remain
• Double maintenance
• Only transitional solution

When useful:

• Short-term action needed
• Limited budget
• Migration not yet possible

2. Rehost (Lift & Shift)

Concept: Move system to modern infrastructure.

Examples:

• On-premise → Cloud
• Physical → Virtualised
• Own data centre → Managed hosting

Advantages:

• No code changes
• Improved scalability
• Lower operating costs

Disadvantages:

• Technical debt remains
• Functionality unchanged
• Cloud benefits not fully utilised

When useful:

• Hardware at end of lifecycle
• Infrastructure modernisation planned
• Quick wins possible

3. Replatform (Lift & Optimise)

Concept: Move system to new platform with minimal adjustments.

Examples:

• Oracle → PostgreSQL
• .NET Framework → .NET 6
• Windows Server 2008 → 2022

Advantages:

• Reduced licence costs
• Improved support
• Performance gains possible

Disadvantages:

• Significant testing effort
• Compatibility issues possible
• Medium project effort

When useful:

• Licence costs problematic
• Platform at end-of-life
• Code fundamentally okay

4. Refactor

Concept: Improve code without changing functionality.

Examples:

• Monolith → Modules
• Spaghetti code → Clean architecture
• Pay down technical debt

Advantages:

• Improved maintainability
• Foundation for further modernisation
• Knowledge is built

Disadvantages:

• Time-consuming
• Risky without good tests
• No immediate business value

When useful:

• System should stay long-term
• Code quality critical
• Team has capacity

5. Rearchitect

Concept: Rebuild system with modern architecture, but preserve core.

Examples:

• Monolith → Microservices
• Client/Server → Cloud-native
• Batch → Event-driven

Advantages:

• Modern architecture
• Scalability
• Future-proof

Disadvantages:

• High effort
• Complex migration
• New operational requirements

When useful:

• Scaling critical
• Modern architecture strategically important
• Long-term investment acceptable

6. Replace

Concept: Replace legacy system with standard software.

Examples:

• Custom development → SaaS
• Old ERP → Modern ERP
• Access DB → Professional solution

Advantages:

• Clean cut
• Modern system
• No maintenance effort

Disadvantages:

• Data migration complex
• Process adaptation necessary
• Vendor dependency

When useful:

• Standard processes
• No differentiation through system
• Modern alternatives available

---

Step-by-Step: The Safe Path

Phase 1: Understand (4-8 weeks)

Goal: Fully understand the legacy system.

Activities:

1. Code Analysis

   • Perform static analysis
   • Map dependencies
   • Quantify technical debt

2. Knowledge Extraction

   • Interviews with users
   • Document business rules
   • Capture edge cases

3. Inventory

   • Document data model
   • Identify interfaces
   • Create performance baselines

Result: Legacy System Map + Business Rules Documentation

Phase 2: Choose Strategy (2-4 weeks)

Goal: Determine the right modernisation approach.

Evaluation Criteria:

Criterion	Encapsulate	Replatform	Rearchitect	Replace
Budget	€	€€	€€€	€€
Time	Weeks	Months	Years	Months
Risk	Low	Medium	High	Medium
Long-term Value	Low	Medium	High	Medium

Phase 3: Strangler Fig Pattern (Ongoing)

Concept: Gradually replace old functionality with new.

Week 1-4: New facade (API Gateway) in front of old system
                          ↓
Week 5-8: Feature A is rebuilt, facade routes there
                          ↓
Week 9-12: Feature B is rebuilt
                          ↓
...repeat until legacy is empty...
                          ↓
Final: Shut down old system

Advantages:

• Rollback possible at any time
• Incremental value gain
• Risk distributed
• Organisation learns along

Phase 4: Data Migration (Parallel)

The underestimated part: Data migration fails more often than code migration.

Steps:

1. Check Data Quality

   • Identify duplicates
   • Find inconsistencies
   • Clean up orphan records

2. Define Mapping

   • Old schema → New schema
   • Transformation rules
   • Validation

3. Migrate Incrementally

   • Historical data first
   • Delta synchronisation
   • Minimal final cutover window

Phase 5: Cutover & Decommissioning

Go-Live Strategy:

Approach	Risk	Effort	Recommended For
Big Bang	High	Low	Small systems
Parallel Run	Medium	High	Critical systems
Phased	Low	Medium	Large organisations
Feature Toggle	Low	Medium	Modern architectures

After Go-Live:

• Monitor old system (is it still used?)
• Monitor database access
• After 3-6 months: Shut down permanently

---

Costs and ROI

Typical Cost Structure

Phase	Share	Example (€500k Project)
Analysis & Planning	10-15%	€50,000-€75,000
Development	50-60%	€250,000-€300,000
Data Migration	15-20%	€75,000-€100,000
Testing	10-15%	€50,000-€75,000
Training & Rollout	5-10%	€25,000-€50,000

ROI Calculation

Costs without modernisation (per year):

• Maintenance: €150,000
• Specialist premium: €50,000
• Downtime costs: €30,000
• Opportunity costs: €100,000
• Total: €330,000/year

Costs with new system (per year):

• Maintenance: €50,000
• Standard developers: €0 premium
• Downtime costs: €5,000
• Opportunity costs: €20,000
• Total: €75,000/year

ROI Calculation:

Modernisation costs: €500,000
Annual savings: €255,000
Break-even: 2 years
5-year ROI: €775,000

---

When You Should NOT Modernise

Scenario 1: System Will Be Shut Down Soon

If the system will be replaced in 2-3 years anyway, modernisation rarely pays off. Better: Stabilise and plan successor in parallel.

Scenario 2: No Sponsor in Management

Without backing from above, modernisation projects fail. First win stakeholders, then start.

Scenario 3: Core Know-how Not Available

If nobody understands the system anymore and no documentation exists, the startup effort is enormous. Sometimes redevelopment is faster.

Scenario 4: The System Works (Really)

Sometimes "legacy" is just a label. If the system runs stably, meets requirements, and has no security risks - why change?

---

Practical Checklist

Before Starting

• Business case created and approved
• Sponsor at management level
• Team with legacy experience
• Documentation of current state
• Risk assessment performed

During Modernisation

• Regular demos to stakeholders
• Rollback plan for each step
• Monitoring of both systems
• Knowledge transfer documented
• Test coverage for migrated features

After Modernisation

• Old system documented and shut down
• Knowledge distributed in team
• Lessons learned documented
• Technical debt process established
• Monitoring and alerting active

---

Conclusion

Legacy modernisation isn't an IT project - it's business transformation. The technical challenges are solvable; the organisational ones determine success or failure.

Key takeaways:

1. Not everything at once - Strangler Fig instead of Big Bang
2. Business first - Understand processes, not just code
3. Data is key - Plan migration as standalone project
4. Distribute risk - Proceed step by step, rollback always possible
5. Bring the team along - Build knowledge, address resistance

---

Next Steps

Do you have a legacy system that needs modernisation?

At Balane Tech, we have experience with complex modernisation projects - from initial analysis to successful cutover. Schedule a free consultation